What each level is called isn’t what makes the rubric holistic — it’s the way the characteristics are all lumped together. You want your loved ones to know what you expect if they should ever make you breakfast in bed.
What each level is called isn’t what makes the rubric holistic — it’s the way the characteristics are all lumped together. You want your loved ones to know what you expect if they should ever make you breakfast in bed.So you give them this holistic rubric: When your breakfast is done, you simply gather your loved ones and say, “I’m sorry my darlings, but that breakfast was just a 2.For a student who really tries hard, it can be heartbreaking to have no idea what she’s doing wrong.
” If the teacher is the explaining kind, he will spend a few minutes breaking down the score.
If not, he’ll say something like, “Read the rubric.” Then the student has to guess which factors had the biggest influence on her score.
Just like with the analytic rubric, if a target was simply met, you can just highlight the appropriate phrase in the center column.
If you’ve never used a single-point rubric, it’s worth a try.
And once all that work is done, (2) Facing a 36-cell table crammed with 8-point font is enough to send most students straight into a nap.
And that means they won’t clearly understand what’s expected of them.Although many holistic rubrics list specific characteristics for each level, the teacher gives only one score, without breaking it down into separate qualities.This often leads the student to approach the teacher and ask, “Why did you give me a 2?This is where we see the main advantage of the analytic rubric: It is also good for the teacher, because it gives her the ability to justify a score on paper, without having to explain everything in a later conversation.Analytic rubrics have two significant disadvantages, however: (1) .[To download a free Microsoft Word template for a holistic rubric, click .] An analytic rubric breaks down the characteristics of an assignment into parts, allowing the scorer to itemize and define exactly what aspects are strong, and which ones need improvement.So for the breakfast in bed example, an analytic rubric would look like this: In this case, you’d give your loved ones a separate score for each category. To make feedback even more targeted, you could also highlight specific phrases in the rubric, like, “the recipient is crowded during the meal” to indicate exactly what went wrong.Writing up descriptors of satisfactory work — completing the “3” column in this rubric, for example — is enough of a challenge on its own.But to have to define all the ways the work could go wrong, and all the ways it could exceed expectations, is a big, big task.The single-point rubric has several advantages: (1) It contains far less language than the analytic rubric, which means .When using full analytic rubrics, I often find that students do things that are not described on the rubric, but still depart from expectations.